Timothy SnyderBlack Earth: The Holocaust as History and Warning

Tim Duggan Books, 2015

by Kelly McFall on January 28, 2016

Timothy Snyder

View on Amazon

It's rare when an academic historian breaks through and becomes a central part of the contemporary cultural conversation.

Timothy Snyder does just this with his book Black Earth: The Holocaust as History and Warning (Tim Duggan Books, 2015).  He does so by boldly arguing that we don't really understand what happened during the Holocaust.  He argues in favor of an emphasis on ideology with Adolf Hitler at the center.  But he also stresses the importance of the experience of occupation and the role of state structures, incentives and punishments.  It was, he suggests, the persistence or disappearance of states that made all the difference in the way the Holocaust emerged over time.

Because of our misunderstanding of the nature of the Holocaust, we've misunderstood the lessons that it should teach us.  Because the world of our time rhymes with that of the Holocaust, this misunderstanding poses real threats to our world.

It's a tremendous book, fully worth of the extensive praise it has received. It will no doubt lead to many conversations among holocaust and genocide scholars alike.

We only had time to touch on the big themes of the book in this interview. Hopefully you'll get a feel for the flavor of his argument and why it's so challenging to the discipline.

{ Comments on this entry are closed }

Abram de SwaanThe Killing Compartments: The Mentality of Mass Murder

January 11, 2016

For a couple of decades, scholars have moved toward a broad consensus that context, rather than ideology, is most important in pushing ordinary men and women to participate in mass murder.  The "situationist paradigm," as Abram de Swaan labels this, concludes from studies by psychologists, sociologists, historians and others, that individuals are malleable, easily influenced […]

Read the full article →

S. Matthew LiaoThe Right to be Loved

January 5, 2016

It seems obvious that children need to be loved, that having a loving home and upbringing is essential to a child's emotional and cognitive development. It is also obvious that, under typical circumstances at least, for every child there are adults who should love them. It is perhaps not surprising, then, that many national and […]

Read the full article →

Michael KimmelAngry White Men: American Masculinity at the End of an Era

December 18, 2015

Michael Kimmel is the Distinguished Professor of Sociology and Gender Studies at Stony Brook University. He is also executive director of the Center for the Study of Men and Masculinities. His book Angry White Men: American Masculinity at the End of an Era (Nation Books, 2013) is an engaging and eye-opening book about the lives […]

Read the full article →

Jennifer MittelstadtThe Rise of the Military Welfare State

December 10, 2015

[Cross-posted from Who Make Cents?] Have you seen those Facebook memes floating around, arguing that we shouldn't support a 15-dollar -per-hour minimum wage for service sector workers because the military doesn't earn a living wage? Jennifer Mittelstadt tells us how these stark lines were drawn between the military and the civilian economy – and on how […]

Read the full article →

Saba MahmoodReligious Difference in a Secular Age: A Minority Report

December 7, 2015

It is commonly thought that violence, injustice, and discrimination against religious minorities, especially in the Middle East, are a product of religious fundamentalism and myopia. Concomitantly, it is often argued, that more of secularism and less of religion represents the solution to this problem. In her stunning new book Religious Difference in a Secular Age: […]

Read the full article →

Jason W. Moore Capitalism in the Web of Life: Ecology and the Accumulation of Capital

December 3, 2015

In Capitalism in the Web of Life: Ecology and the Accumulation of Capital (Verso, 2015), author Jason W. Moore seeks to undermine popular understandings of the relationship among society, environment, and capitalism. Rather, than seeing society and environment as acting on an external, nonhuman nature, Moore wants us to recognize capitalism-in-nature. For Moore, seeing society […]

Read the full article →

Carlos FraenkelTeaching Plato in Palestine: Philosophy in a Divided World

December 1, 2015

We tend to think of Philosophy as a professional academic subject that is taught in college classes, with its own rather specialized problems, vocabularies, and methods. But we also know that the discipline has its roots in the Socratic activity of trying to incite debate and critical reflection among our fellow citizens. That is, we […]

Read the full article →

Phillip RoscoeA Richer Life: How Economics can Change the Way We Think and Feel

November 19, 2015

So many of our social questions are now the subject of analysis from economics. In A Richer Life: How Economics can Change the Way We Think and Feel (Penguin, 2015), Phillip Roscoe, a reader at the University of St Andrew's School of Management, offers a critique of the long march of economics into social life. The book covers […]

Read the full article →

John Durham PetersThe Marvelous Clouds: Toward a Philosophy of Elemental Media

November 17, 2015

[Cross-posted from the NBN Seminar] John Durham Peters' wonderful new book is a brilliant and beautifully-written consideration of natural environments as subjects for media studies. Accessible and informative for a broad readership. The Marvelous Clouds: Toward a Philosophy of Elemental Media (University of Chicago Press, 2015) is structured as a series of meditations on and explorations of water, fire, air, earth, […]

Read the full article →